Popular Posts

2/3/24

A Man Who Loved the "Least of Them" for 50 Years



   



A Report by Robert R. Schwarz    


The priest is a man anointed by tradition to shed
                                      blood, not as soldier, through courage, not as
                                      the magistrate, through justice, but as Jesus 
                                      Christ , through love. The priest is a man of
                                      sacrifice; by it, each day , reconciling heaven
                                      and earth , and by it, each day, announcing to
                                       every soul the primordial truths of life , of
                                       death, and of resurrection .
                            --Fr. Henri-Dominique,  O.P.
        
" God  is everywhere and in all people. "
                                           (Fr. Joe Carolin, Chaplin, South Mountain
                                                   Restoration Center) 

    
On an April afternoon a decade or so ago, automobiles from most of the eastern United States were seen winding their way on a forest road somewhere between the Tuscarora and South Mountains of Pennsylvania, all heading to the remote St. Ignatius Loyola church built in 1795.  The passengers were close friends, priests colleagues, nuns, several well-wishers and cousins   of a priest they all called "Joey."  They had been invited by him, Fr. Joe C. Carolin, to his 50th anniversary of priestly ministry. In various ways, Joey had blessed the lives of most of them. And for that, they really loved this man—and his humor. 
            " He talks to terminally ill  patients who can neither respond nor hear , but I've seen them joyful just to be in the chapel during one of his Masses, " said friend Frank Penna. " He gives them hugs just to get them through the day. And these  are  people who are dying all the time. " Another  friend at Joey's anniversary  told me, "His  great gift is to implement  his deep religious philosophy with common people. " He's still doing all this  today, I was told... 
            

        When the cars were parked on higher ground and camera shutters had captured the story-book scene of the immense countryside below this nearby small church tucked away in trees, the 180 guests walked slowly to the church door; some paused to look at an outside statue of a young female Scotch-Irish   settler, the only survivor of a Shawnee Indian attack in 1758.
          On the altar that day, "Joey"(everyone called him that) announced that his homily would be simple. This priest was mindful of   a close friend in the congregation who was an agnostic, and also of several other friends of different faiths. (He had told them that they do not need to follow common  Catholic rites at this celebratory mass.)   
      He expressed his love for Jesus and the love he had for everyone there. After the Eucharist, everyone headed downstairs to enjoy home-cooked country food, robust band music, and the much laughter and rekindling of old friendships.
        
Some of Fr. Joey's family at his 50th anniversary
 
Comments that evening remained cheerful and empathetic about Joey's life for the last 38 years as chaplain at the nearby South Mountain Restoration Center.   
"I can't think of a more depressing job, " I was told at the dinner table by Frank Penna, a close friend of Joey's who shared with Joey in the 1960's their mutual interest in social change programs supported by President Lyndon Johnson.   Another friend, Sr. Maria   Cieslinski, said, "I've known Father Joe for 49 years. He's kept me on the straight and narrow. Sometimes it's been entertaining. He has a great sense of humor, but sometimes it got me aggravated," she chided. " I'll never forget when he asked me, while reaching for his own wallet, what I could do to help a family about to lose their mobile home.

South Mountain Restoration Center   
  The archives of this restoration center describes it this way :  It sits atop the Blue Ridge Mountains. From the center's seventh floor, an observer can  gaze over the seemingly  endless tract of the Michaux State Forest  or search for a glimpse of Gettysburg, tucked in a valley to the east.  The road leading to the center  rises from the town of Mont Alto at the foot of  the mountains and climbs five miles in switchbacks past the center to the village of South Mountain.  It is an unlikely site for a geriatric center,  perched amid acres of forest land, where deer, snakes, and ruffed grouse live, but the story of the South Mountain Restoration Center twists and turns like the road that leads to its door. 
            Joey for his 38 years here  had a dynamic role. Most priests might dread his assignment, especially in the early 1900's when the center cared for World War I victims of mustard gas and patients with terminal  tuberculosis. Clearly, the challenge when Joey arrived  was huge and demanding.     He was constantly moving  from room to room , ministering to an eventual population of 800 patients housed  in a seven-story building. Surrounding  it were other restoration buildings— now closed and "in moth balls " , Joey told me during one of many of our talks.   Their scrubby exteriors today are grisly reminders of  patients who died there during the center's early years . Today they still come to the center as old people without money , friends or family. They are feeble and physically and mentally ill. Joey's job for almost four decades was to be their friend , pray daily for them and give them hope and help them to have had a "good death." 
                                      "Saving His Soul" by Following His Vocation 
       
          I asked Joey about his  early , life-defining  events. " I was raised Catholic, was an altar   boy," he began. "My grandfather prayed nine Rosaries each day . Mother  was always empathetic, caring for the poor and people with disabilities, and that gave me empathy for  elderly and disabled people.  I was always interested in the things of God, but at first I wanted to be a physician. But   I remember what a priest said at a high school retreat I was on: 'It would be    harder to save your soul if you didn't follow your vocation of what God wanted you to do . '  And that was pretty much  when I decided to enter the seminary."
       
St. Ignatius Loyola Church 
  
Did Joey ever think seriously about marriage ? He answered with his usual candor: "Yes, continuously, for a number of years in the seminary and early years of my priesthood.  It was a struggle, but  gradually I got more and more confirmed in leading a celibate life. "  Joey went on a Jesuit retreat, where he made a firm decision  to become a priest.  
Subsequent to his mother's death in 1979 was a "tough time" for  Joey. He  remembers  his first two years at South Mountain as  a "really tricky balancing act  between  being a parish priest and also, then,  as a college campus chaplain .  "I felt like a single parent of triplets. "
           I asked if he then had a goal . "Yes, " he said with a smile and one word added with  irony: "Survival."  His smile , I thought, had been implanted  by  the many times he had  hugged  and held hands of people  who had nothing to give back, particularly those with damaged brains and those disabled from childhood from  abuse and violence. 
          During our first interview  many years ago, I had noted on Joey's resume that his seminary instruction included religion studies in England and Belgium; and so I inquired about  his theology. " Psychological understanding of human behavior has an interface with spirituality, " he began.  " But I don't think you can reduce spirituality to psychology, but if you ignore the emotional underpinnings, you're missing an important understanding . The interaction of the church's theology with science  helps  purify its understanding of how God is at work. The Gospel , as I try to engage in it, is a  vision ; but it's not alive unless you try to incorporate it into the values of life as best you can.  Examine your beliefs and you'll get power and freedom. "
          Does anything about the Catholic Church bother  him ?  "The past sex abuses by priests , " he replied." It was a powerful indictment…but I've know so many  wonderful colleagues in the church. " 
More About Fr. Carolin at Age 78
          Three years after his 50th anniversary as a priest, Joey and I had a long telephone conversation during his so-called retirement.  I found him  still unmoved by  flattering words about him .  He told me  he keeps busy by attending "special meetings" at the restoration center, where he  also now teaches a Bible class and offers a monthly anointing ( healing ) Mass , which he says "is a real workout . "  On his weekday and Sunday task list are names of  various churches in the area which have asked him to preside at a Mass.  He jokingly refers to his presence at these churches as their  soup 'd jour.  
          Any goals ? "Just  to keep at it ,"  Joey replied.  He misses  face-to-face ministering as he did daily at the restoration center, but adds, "I'm also relieved." Anything sadden him? " All my  good priest friends who have died. " .
          Joey admits that at age  78,  holy service work is now "harder " and that he's had  a loss of energy  and now has  body  balancing  issues. He no longer cooks dinner  ( which often was spaghetti, his  favorite ) for a gathering  of friends in his countryside home . And fun?... This night he was going out with friends to a dinner theatre.
          I had to ask:  "Joey , what in the world has kept you going all  these  years , work for which few humans would not  have the necessary fortitude ? "  He gave a typical Joey reply: " I just  did my duties. " He likes Pope Francis. "He's a very humble prophetic man. He listens to people. " As for the American culture today,  he commented, "There's a lot of good out there , a  lot  of people who are Christ-like.  If you are trying to help people, that doesn't mean you approve of what they're  doing. "
           
Relaxing after the big event with his cousin,
Mary Alice Davis-Schwarz, at whose marriage he
 presided 27 years ago. 

This report was originally posted July 27, 2019 and re-edited Dec. 25, 2022. Two  memories of Joey remain strong: One is  from his 50th anniversary gathering  when, speaking from the church altar, he described a scene  many years ago when a then-young  Scott Davis , Joey's nephew,  and Joey's father were lying on the floor  playing  some game and  enjoying each other's company . 
       Now looking at his friends in the pews and restraining his emotion, Fr. Carolin said,  "The memory of that reminds me so strongly of the fatherly  relationship each of us today has with God ."         
 
   "Everybody who knew my cousin Joey also learned to love him, " my wife said. For the next three days,  her words gave birth--thanks to the  Holy Spirit, I believe-- to epiphanies about my faith life and God . They are truths, I must confess, which many people come to realize much sooner in life than I did. Here they are:

 It's not about me but Thee and others, dear God. 

The comforts I truly need come only from God, more so than the "pats on my back" I seem to require. 

Accept the Biblical truth that Jesus, whom I love as a personal friend, gives me  a love I must share with others, even those whom I think  don't deserve it. 

NEXT   SUNDAY: 

"A War Veteran Deacon Who 
Left His Comfort Zone and
 Learned to Love "

The End
All comments are welcome at
rrschwarz777@gmail.com
© 2024  Robert R. Schwarz


No comments:

Post a Comment